Judges 2007

[gb]

nappyneddy said:

GB said:

GB

I would imagine old fasioned, lots of bone no rp/shp.

Nappyneddy - Surely you would know, so why not enlighten us?

Mr Parker Jones - likes a square pony and is known to be partial to a familiar face!

Havent got a clue what your on about.....i do not know a Mrs Andrews Horsegate stud..!!!.....think youve got your wires crossed somewhere

Sorry nappyneddy - post was somewhat confusing, my answer was in reference to your particular question.....

[ferret]

anyone know what Mrs P Cambell will like in novice kingsford PUk ...change of judge for me ps i have a conni

[goldengirl]

Does anyone know what Mrs M Cartlidge likes? I have a Black sec D?

[marge]

True to type, mannerly and a goer!
Fair lady that one

[area 20]

ferret said:

anyone know what Mrs P Cambell will like in novice kingsford PUk ...change of judge for me ps i have a conni

Unless you are from Area 20 - forget it. Remember HOYS

[I think]

marge said:

True to type, mannerly and a goer!
Fair lady that one

I am not sure but I think she is the mother of Katie Carter - if so will like them to go well.

[goldengirl]

Thanks for that info marge! much appreciated!!!

[volatis]

Can i ask peoples opinions of showing under Vin Toulson - is he facey?

[ferret]

area said:

ferret said:

anyone know what Mrs P Cambell will like in novice kingsford PUk ...change of judge for me ps i have a conni

Unless you are from Area 20 - forget it. Remember HOYS

oh dear am area 5 oh well paid entries now may as well give it a go !!!

[help cuddy]

help does anyone know who is judging the cuddy at ponies uk, and what would they like??!!??

[Vinny]

volatis said:

Can i ask peoples opinions of showing under Vin Toulson - is he facey?

Very hot on conformation and will do as he wants. Will sometimes forgive a genuinely true to type animal with good conformation if it makes a mistake.

[any1]

any1 knows who is judging nps area 4 and what they go for please?

[armada]

Any info on Mrs J seymour for riding pony breeding? She's judging us at Romsey, and the one report from a friend so far has'nt filled me with confidence!!!

[ferret]

spanish said:

Any info on Mrs J seymour for riding pony breeding? She's judging us at Romsey, and the one report from a friend so far has'nt filled me with confidence!!!

i would go anyway ..watch what she goes for and then make your decision on wether to go under her again !!! I was told of lots of people that the judges at PUk would not like my conni ( nearly didnt go )...went ...and she did like him !!!
You need to be in it to win it !!
Good luck

[armada]

All systems go Ferret, just wondered, certain types of judge just love her (the mare that is) usually the older more trad type. We are in the first class, so hopefully the judge will be bright eyed and bushy tailed and it'll work in our favour.

[ferret]

Good luck armada !

[bow wow]

spanish said:

Any info on Mrs J seymour for riding pony breeding? She's judging us at Romsey, and the one report from a friend so far has'nt filled me with confidence!!!

Heard she judged the doggie dresage at PUK

[Deleted]

P Campbell loves my Dartmoor stallion

[armada]

bow said:

spanish said:

Any info on Mrs J seymour for riding pony breeding? She's judging us at Romsey, and the one report from a friend so far has'nt filled me with confidence!!!

Heard she judged the doggie dresage at PUK

Can you expand on Doggie Dressage - or was it exactly that, dogs doing dressage???

[Milliesmum]

Please use this thread for information on judges, not for discussing the merits or otherwise of individual judges.

[hello]

hello

oh said:

John Conifey? He is a horrendous face judge - do a search for the east of england thread to see what people thought of his judging there.

he had a horse to win that kicked another in the line up, as well as misbehaving on go-round - no surprise that a well known producer was on board

Facey facey facey

yes i agree with you. was competing at east of e. judging appalling in my eyes

[ponypony]

hi all. can anyone tell ma what mr p boustead is likely to go for in a ridden m&m large?? thanks

[Crook Kid]

Having seen that the BSPS Lead Rein thread has been locked it looked worth pointing out that many judges on this site have been named and inappropriate comment made and yet this thread has not been removed.
Is this site out to protect some judges and not others?
If the BSPS HOYS M&M judge did as was suggested and the incident has been reported then we should all be informed and warned of the person involved.
No pony or competitor was named on the BSPS thread and if the incident has been reported then we must all hope for the good of fair competition that the BSPS will see fit to act and deal with the judge concerned appropriately. if the allegations are true it would be an unforgivable offence.
What was the "favour" in return for?

[Milliesmum]

I have only just taken on this role and cannot go back through every post and remove every name. But whilst I am on line I will do my best to make sure that it operates within the rules.

I may not get it right first time every time. But I am doing my best. On the thread in question the pony was named and I removed the name. Twice. As I have said previously I do not know the truth of the situation and therefore must remain impartial. There are proper channels to take action against judges you feel are acting inappropriately.

Whilst I have every sympathy for people who feel they have been unfairly treated by judges, or that they have lost out due to favours being given, if I am not privy to all the facts I cannot take sides.

The rules of the site ask you not to post liable or defamatory statements. I am just trying to uphold these rules.

[Buddy]

Go Millesmum Go

[what]

what will fiona cameron go for?

[Guestless]

what said:

what will fiona cameron go for?

She's one of my favourite judges. I've been top, middle and bottom of the line up when she's judged me, but I've always felt that I've been placed where I should be. She likes them to move well and have manners and seems to know bred types very well too.

I think this is one Olympia qualifier that it will be difficult to predict.

[Guestless]

Crook said:

No pony or competitor was named on the BSPS thread and if the incident has been reported then we must all hope for the good of fair competition that the BSPS will see fit to act and deal with the judge concerned appropriately.

See the BSPS Lead Rein Thread has been removed again. Why has this judge been protected when this thread has allowed so many others to be humiliated often without justification.
[/quote]

The removal of the thread is nothing to do with protecting the judge. We have been requested to remove it and, as always, we do delete threads where requested so to do. If you have a problem with how the class was judged, then I suggest you take it up with the BSPS through their official complaints procedure.

This thread is for discussing judges and not individual classes. Any future posts on here regarding this incident will be deleted without further comment.

[maria]

guestless said:

Crook said:

No pony or competitor was named on the BSPS thread and if the incident has been reported then we must all hope for the good of fair competition that the BSPS will see fit to act and deal with the judge concerned appropriately.

See the BSPS Lead Rein Thread has been removed again. Why has this judge been protected when this thread has allowed so many others to be humiliated often without justification.

The removal of the thread is nothing to do with protecting the judge. We have been requested to remove it and, as always, we do delete threads where requested so to do. If you have a problem with how the class was judged, then I suggest you take it up with the BSPS through their official complaints procedure.

This thread is for discussing judges and not individual classes. Any future posts on here regarding this incident will be deleted without further comment.[/quote]


Please can someone advise me how i can speak to a moderator directly, and not on the open screen.. thankyou.

[Admin]

As a member you can send a pm (personal message)
Use that if you need to contact a mod.
One will answer you ASAP.